Heated mattress pad vs electric blanket: which is better for you?

By
A hand pulling a duvet back over a white heated mattress pad fitted on a bed, with its controller

Both will warm up a cold bed, but they do it in different ways. A heated mattress pad sits under you, fitted over the mattress like a sheet. An electric blanket sits on top of you, like a throw or a duvet. Here's how to choose.

The short answer

  • Choose a heated mattress pad if you want to get into a warm bed, keep your usual duvet and have it stay put all winter.
  • Choose an electric blanket if you also want warmth on the sofa, or you like a heavy layer on top of you.

Side by side

Heated mattress pad Electric blanket
Where it goes On the mattress, under your sheet On top of you, under or over the duvet
Heat From below, so the whole bed warms evenly From above, warm where it touches you
Stays in place Yes, it's fitted with an elastic skirt Can slide off or bunch up
Your own duvet Keep it Adds a layer, or replaces it
Sofa use No Yes
Washing Usually machine washable once the controller is off Usually machine washable once the controller is off

Warmth

Warm air rises, so heat from below spreads through the bed and under your duvet. Most people pre-warm the bed with a pad for about 15 minutes, then turn it down or off when they get in. A blanket on top warms the front of you first and can feel heavy if you sleep hot.

Fit and comfort

A mattress pad is thin and flat, so you barely notice it under your sheet. Check the size: a full pad is 54 x 75 in and won't reach the edges of a queen. A blanket needs no fitting, but it moves around as you sleep.

Running cost

Both use little power. Our pad is rated 100 W, so even on full power for 8 hours it uses at most about 0.8 kWh, roughly 15 cents at a typical US electricity price, and much less on low or once you switch it off.

Safety

  • With either one: never use it folded or bunched, never use it wet, and don't put one heated product on top of another.
  • Use a pad only on a mattress, under a sheet, and don't tuck it in tightly.
  • Look for an automatic shut-off. Our pad switches itself off after 10 hours.
  • Neither is for babies, young children or anyone who can't feel heat or switch it off. If you have diabetes, poor circulation or a medical condition, or are pregnant, ask your doctor first.

Which suits you

  • Cold sleeper in a cold bedroom: a mattress pad.
  • Couples who sleep at different temperatures: a mattress pad set low, with a lighter duvet on the warm sleeper's side.
  • Cold on the sofa as well as in bed: an electric blanket, or a pad for bed plus a heated wrap blanket for the sofa.

Our pick

Our heated mattress pad is soft coral fleece with a deep fitted skirt, five heat levels from about 86°F to 108°F, a 10-hour auto-off and a controller that unplugs so you can machine wash it. See how to use a heated mattress pad safely.

Quick answers

Can I sleep with a heated mattress pad on?

It switches itself off after 10 hours, but most people warm the bed first and then turn it to a low level or off.

Can I use both together?

No. Don't put a heated blanket on top of a heated pad.